"Shadow of the Erdtree" is considered more challenging than "Elden Ring." Many players, even long-time veterans, have found the DLC to be extremely difficult, citing that their stats and levels do not provide adequate protection against powerful enemies. Some players have described the bosses as overtuned and aggressive, requiring significant grinding and strategic adjustments to overcome.
The enemy and boss designs in "Shadow of the Erdtree" are challenging players and causing mixed reactions. While some appreciate the high difficulty and variety of enemies, others find the encounters too punishing and frustrating, leading to a "Mixed" review score on Steam. Players are advised to be patient, explore more, and adapt their tactics and builds to overcome the challenges.
Negative reviews of "Shadow of the Erdtree" commonly cite the game's difficulty as the main issue, with players feeling that their stats and levels do not provide adequate protection against enemies. Some players also complain about imbalanced boss fights and unpolished gameplay experiences.