The T-shirt design features a café with a red flower vine above the door, a narrow staircase, and a white "cafe" sign, closely resembling the appearance of Caffe de Martini in Brooklyn. The owner, Stefano de Martini, also noted the Vespa parked outside the shop in the design, which he himself owns and often parks in front of the café.
A local resident highlighted nine specific details on a Prospect Heights Facebook group, pointing out similarities between the image on the T-shirt and Caffe de Martini's storefront, such as railing placement, shop molding, and sign location, arguing that these elements were too specific to be a coincidence.
Stefano de Martini, owner of Caffe de Martini, has reached out to PacSun with the hope of "collaborating" and earning a percentage of profits from the T-shirt featuring his shop's image. He has not yet taken legal action but is seeking recognition and compensation for the unauthorized use of his storefront's likeness.